Am I on track for retirement? A better test than savings by age

Somewhere in your 40s or 50s, the question shows up: am I on track for retirement? The usual answer is a multiple of your salary. The most widely quoted version says to have one times your salary saved by 30, three times by 40, six by 50, eight by 60 and ten by 67.

It's a fine place to start. But it answers a different question from the one you asked. It tells you whether you look like an average saver at your age. It doesn't tell you whether your savings can pay for the retirement you expect.

What savings-by-age rules measure

A salary multiple is worked backward from a typical household: one that retires at a typical age, wants to replace a typical share of its pay, and gets typical markets along the way. If that describes you, the rule is a decent check.

What it leaves out is everything that makes your answer yours:

  • Your spending. Two households with the same income can expect to spend very different amounts in retirement. The rule assumes they spend the same.
  • Social Security. Your benefit depends on your own earnings record and when you claim. The rule bakes in an average.
  • Where the money sits. A dollar in a pre-tax 401(k) and a dollar in a Roth are worth different amounts once taxes come due. The rule counts them the same.
  • When you stop. Retiring at 60 instead of 67 means seven fewer years of saving and seven more years of drawing. The rule picks the age for you.

Two households, same savings, different answers

Take two couples. Both are 50, earn $150,000 a year between them, and have $900,000 saved: six times salary, right on the rule. Both save $30,000 a year and expect $4,000 a month in Social Security between them from 67. Both would like to stop working around 60.

By the rule, they're equally on track. What separates them is the spending they expect in retirement: $85,000 a year for the first couple, $115,000 for the second.

Run both through the free When can you retire calculator. It grows their savings at 3% a year above inflation, the worst 30-year return US stocks have delivered on record, allows for taxes at a blended 12%, and asks the money to last to 90:

  • Spending $85,000, the first couple can retire at 58.
  • Spending $115,000, the second couple can retire at 63.

Turn the question around and the gap shows in dollars. If they keep saving until 60, their savings and Social Security can support about $100,400 a year from then on, on that same test. Enter $100,400 as the spending and the calculator shows 60; a hundred dollars more and it shows 61. The first couple's $85,000 sits $15,400 under that. The second couple's $115,000 is $14,600 over it.

Same age, same income, same savings, same multiple. One couple is on track to stop at 60 and the other isn't. The rule can't tell them apart, because the thing that separates them is spending, and the rule never asks about it.

To reproduce these figures, enter a current age of 50, savings of $900,000, annual savings of $30,000, Social Security of $4,000 a month (both benefits together) claimed at 67, and the spending above.

What "on track" means here

On track means your savings, your income and Social Security can support the spending you expect, every year of your plan, even in the worst 30-year market on record. That's the test behind Confidence Spend™: what your savings can support each year, set beside what you expect to spend. Under it, you're on track. Over it, the gap is in dollars a year, and you can see what closes it.

It's never a check against an earlier plan or a target someone else set. It's your savings today against your own spending, on a deliberately conservative floor.

What moves the answer while you're still saving

For a saver, the levers look different than they do for someone already retired. Here's how each one moved the second couple's numbers in the same calculator:

  • Saving more. Adding $10,000 a year, to $40,000, moves their earliest age from 63 to 62 and lifts what their savings can support from 60 by about $5,000 a year.
  • Expecting to spend less. Planning on $105,000 instead of $115,000 moves their age from 63 to 61.
  • Stopping later. Each year past 60 adds roughly $7,000 a year to what their savings can support: about $107,000 from 61, $114,000 from 62 and $121,700 from 63.

None of these is the answer on its own. They're trade-offs between working longer, saving more now and spending more later, and seeing each one in dollars is what makes the choice yours.

Checking in as you save

While you're saving, the number isn't fixed. It climbs as you add to your accounts and moves with markets. Lumifin works out Confidence Spend™ on your real accounts, taxes and healthcare, and each quarter you enter your balances to measure the return you actually got and refresh the outlook. "Am I on track?" gets a current answer instead of a once-a-decade guess.

Find your own answer

The When can you retire calculator takes a minute, and rough numbers are fine: your age, your savings, what you add each year, what you expect to spend and your Social Security estimate. For the version on your real accounts, taxes and healthcare, Lumifin works out Confidence Spend™ and sets your spending beside it.

Educational only, not financial or tax advice. Everyone's situation is different. Model your own numbers, or check with a fiduciary advisor or CPA, before acting.

← All posts

See what your savings can support

Lumifin works out Confidence Spend™ from your real accounts, taxes, healthcare and Social Security, sets the spending you expect beside it, and shows how far under or over you are.

Try Confidence Spend™ free →

30-day free trial · $199/yr founding member price, locked in for life (later $299/yr).

Want to see it first? Book a 30-minute demo with me →